50 Dark Would You Rather Questions (Vote Live)
50 dark Would You Rather questions: grim, creepy, but PG-13. Vote live on 15 and see how others chose, plus 35 more to read aloud.
These are dark Would You Rather questions: death, ghosts, disasters and the choices nobody wants to make. They're grim but PG-13, made for campfires, sleepovers and late nights when the conversation has already turned strange. The first 15 are live polls, so vote and find out how morbid everyone else is. Back to the main collection →
Death and Destiny
Would you rather know how old you'll be when you die or where it will happen?
Would you rather be forgotten the day you die or remembered for one mistake?
Would you rather die peacefully at 70 or live to 100 stuck in bed?
Would you rather haunt your enemies or protect your friends as a ghost?
Would you rather attend your own funeral or read your own obituary early?
Creepy Scenarios
Would you rather spend a night in a haunted house or a night alone in a forest?
Would you rather hear whispers no one else hears or see shadows no one else sees?
Would you rather be lost at sea or lost in a cave?
Would you rather find a stranger's diary that mentions you or a photo of you sleeping you didn't take?
Would you rather live next to a cemetery or above a morgue?
Grim Trade-offs
Would you rather be the last survivor of a zombie outbreak or the first one infected?
Would you rather live through the plague years or the ice age?
Would you rather know every secret your family keeps or keep all of yours buried?
Would you rather spend a year in solitary confinement or ten years in a crowded cell?
Would you rather have a double replace you or be erased from every photo?
More dark questions (read-aloud list)
- Would you rather know how long everyone around you has left or have no idea about anyone?
- Would you rather be the villain everyone remembers or the hero nobody knows?
- Would you rather spend eternity as a ghost in your home or in a busy airport?
- Would you rather outlive everyone you love or go before all of them?
- Would you rather be trapped in a horror movie or in a disaster movie?
- Would you rather be hunted by a pack of wolves or a single bear?
- Would you rather hear your house creak every night or find your doors open every morning?
- Would you rather be the only person who remembers the old world or forget it like everyone else?
- Would you rather wake up in a morgue or in a stranger's house?
- Would you rather survive a shipwreck alone or a plane crash with strangers?
- Would you rather have your reflection lag a second behind or move a second ahead?
- Would you rather get a warning letter from your future self or no warning at all?
- Would you rather be cursed with bad luck or cursed with nightmares?
- Would you rather read a list of everyone who secretly dislikes you or never know?
- Would you rather live where everyone can read your thoughts or where nobody can hear you speak?
- Would you rather be lost in the woods at night or locked in an empty mall at night?
- Would you rather be followed by a ghost or by a crow that never leaves?
- Would you rather find out your house was built on a graveyard or that a crime happened there?
- Would you rather have your phone camera turn on by itself or your voice assistant start whispering?
- Would you rather spend a night in an abandoned asylum or an abandoned amusement park?
- Would you rather know the exact moment the world ends or be surprised?
- Would you rather be frozen and revived in 500 years or never be revived at all?
- Would you rather be haunted by a ghost who is friendly but loud or silent but creepy?
- Would you rather lose your shadow or lose your reflection?
- Would you rather be stuck in a dark elevator or a dark submarine?
- Would you rather be the town's only witness to a crime or the town's main suspect?
- Would you rather inherit a cursed house or a cursed painting?
- Would you rather see the world through a security camera or through a stranger's eyes?
- Would you rather have one day left to live or one year with no memory?
- Would you rather spend your afterlife reliving your worst day or your most boring day?
- Would you rather be chased by something you can see or something you can only hear?
- Would you rather live in a ghost town or a town where nobody ever sleeps?
- Would you rather know every lie you've been told or every truth you've missed?
- Would you rather face your greatest fear once or a mild fear every day?
- Would you rather be the first to find an alien body or the last to hear about it?
Want to run one of these as a live vote with your group? Start one here — it takes 30 seconds and you get a link that updates as people vote.