50 Hard Would You Rather Questions (Vote Live)

These are the hard Would You Rather questions, the ones with no easy answer. Money against meaning, memory against freedom, the people you love against everyone else. Use them when a conversation needs to get real, or when you want to watch friends agonize. The first 15 are live polls, so vote and see how close the split is. Back to the main collection →

Money vs. Meaning

Impossible Trade-offs

The Hardest Ones

More hard questions (read-aloud list)

1. Would you rather be loved by everyone but never love back, or love deeply but never be loved back?
2. Would you rather have unlimited money but no free time, or unlimited free time but no money?
3. Would you rather know how every story ends or never be surprised again?
4. Would you rather be remembered forever for something bad or forgotten after something great?
5. Would you rather give up your favorite food forever or your favorite hobby forever?
6. Would you rather live in a perfect world without free will or a messy world with it?
7. Would you rather save five strangers or one person you love?
8. Would you rather have to be completely honest for a year or never be able to apologize?
9. Would you rather lose your sight or your hearing?
10. Would you rather be stuck at your current age forever or age twice as fast?
11. Would you rather have a famous parent who ignores you or an unknown parent who adores you?
12. Would you rather fail at your dream or succeed at something you don't care about?
13. Would you rather be able to heal others but not yourself, or heal yourself but not others?
14. Would you rather have one true friend or a hundred acquaintances?
15. Would you rather know everyone's real opinion of you or have everyone know your real opinion of them?
16. Would you rather live without art or without science?
17. Would you rather restart your life at age 10 with your memories or keep your current life?
18. Would you rather be rich in a country at war or poor in a country at peace?
19. Would you rather never feel pain or never feel fear?
20. Would you rather take a pill that makes you happy forever or stay exactly as you are?
21. Would you rather end world hunger or end all disease?
22. Would you rather always be right or always be kind?
23. Would you rather know the truth behind every conspiracy theory or never hear about one again?
24. Would you rather give up your phone forever or give up travel forever?
25. Would you rather be a genius nobody believes or an average person everybody trusts?
26. Would you rather have a long, boring life or a short, exciting one?
27. Would you rather live in your favorite city with no friends or a boring town with all of them?
28. Would you rather lose every photo you've ever taken or every message you've ever sent?
29. Would you rather be able to undo one decision or redo one day?
30. Would you rather have a job that changes the world or a job that lets you see the world?
31. Would you rather know you'll succeed or enjoy the process of trying?
32. Would you rather be the last person on Earth or one of eight billion with no privacy?
33. Would you rather never age physically or never age mentally?
34. Would you rather keep a secret that hurts you or share one that hurts someone else?
35. Would you rather get the answer to one question or be able to ask anyone anything?

Want to run one of these as a live vote with your group? Start one here — it takes 30 seconds and you get a link that updates as people vote.